Responding- Really Responding- to Other Students' Writing

     This article talks about responding to a students paper the right way. It gives you tips on how to respond and what not to do. It lets you know that your not the writer your just the reader and not to rewrite anything just gives tips. This article gives you a good list of things to look for and comment on.
     The author of this article argued his point well. He lets you know what to do word for word. He does not leave anything out he tells you exactly what to do and how to do it. I do not think he left anything out in this article I think he did a great job at telling me everything you need to know about responding to a students paper. I am not left with any questions because he tells everything you need to know in the article.
      I agree with the author on this article. He lets me know the right and wrong things to do on responding to a students paper. I am glad I got to read this article because I now know what to do in class on Thursday. I think this will also help me later in life also.
     I think this whole article is great. I dont see one line that stands out to me. If I had to pick one line though I would have to say that "you're not the writer you'er the reader" because I think in the past people that have read my papers have thought they were the writer not the reader. This lets you know that you'er just there to help the writer out not to rewrite the paper. I think this was a good line but I like the whole article.